New Documentary on The Gulag Archipelago

Slice Full Doc have posted a new documentary on The Gulag Archipelago. While it contains several inaccuracies and strangely slanted views, it is overall useful, in our view, and we thought it worth re-posting. It is 53 minutes long.

Happy 107th Birthday, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

As is our custom, we share with you a quote from the great man, on his birthday.

“Macbeth’s self-justifications were feeble—and his conscience devoured him. Yes, even Iago was a little lamb too. The imagination and the spiritual strength of Shakespeare’s evildoers stopped short at a dozen corpses. Because they had no ideology.

Ideology—that is what gives evildoing its long-sought justification and gives the evildoer the necessary steadfastness and determination….”
— Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago, part 1, chapter 4, "The Bluecaps"

Solzhenitsyn Brothers Unveil Plaque in Paris

“Here, at the YMCA-PRESS publishing house, on 28 December 1973, was published the gulag archipelago of aleksandr solzhenitsyn (1918–2008), Russian Writer, Nobel Laureate in Literature for 1970, Great figure in the resistance to totalitarianism.”

On 30 January 2025, brothers Ignat and Stephan Solzhenitsyn participated in the formal dedication of a new plaque in Paris, affixed to the side of the building at 11, rue de la Montagne-Sainte-Geneviève, the legendary headquarters of the Russian-émigré publishing house, YMCA-Press, where the very first edition of The Gulag Archipelago was published 50 years ago—on 28 December 1973.

There were several speakers at the unveiling ceremony, including Madame Laurence Patrice, vice-mayor of Paris (the text of her speech here) and Madame Florence Berthout, the mayor of the 5th arrondissement, and Melanie Struve-Rakovitch, representing YMCA-Press and Les Éditeurs Réunis. (For a video of Ignat Solzhenitsyn’s speech, scroll down in this post.)

The event was covered by the French press, including this report in Le Monde newspaper (paywall). Read it in PDF below.

Luminaries at Paris dedication

Stephan and Ignat Solzhenitsyn

Here below is video of a portion of Ignat Solzhenitsyn’s speech. The full French text of his speech can be read here; for English and Russian translations, scroll further down in this post.

More than Just Harrowing

Over at The Dispatch, Flagg Taylor examines the enduring significance of The Gulag Archipelago.

“Yes, we are called to bear witness as Solzhenitsyn prosecutes his case against one of the most monstrous tyrannies in human history. We are called to observe “the special process of the narrowing of the intellectual and spiritual horizon of a human being, the reduction of a human being to an animal and the process of dying alive.” We must not look away. But Solzhenitsyn’s genius in this book is that he calls us to take the stand. The “experiment” that is Gulag Archipelago is full of horror, indignation, drama, courage, and humility. He calls us to wonder about our own inclinations and temptations as questions are put to us. How would our conduct measure up? Which turn would we have taken at the great fork of camp life?

These are dreadful but needful questions. Solzhenitsyn reminds us in his foreword to the one-volume abridgement of Gulag: “Alas, all the evil of the twentieth century is possible everywhere on earth.” It’s a difficult lesson, but one that readers must continue to take away from this uncategorizable and astonishing book.”
— Flagg Taylor

Solzhenitsyn and the Life of Truth

Over at National Review, Elizabeth Edwards Spalding writes about the current plight of Alexei Navalny and about the impact of The Gulag Archipelago.

“Augustinian at his Christian core, Solzhenitsyn offers that it was during his suffering in the Gulag that “I sensed within myself the first stirrings of good.” In poetry that he composed and memorized in the camp, he reflects on rediscovering his belief in God: “Though I renounced You, You were with me!” For Solzhenitsyn, the heavy load he was permitted to carry away from his Gulag years led to the “essential experience” — and understanding — of “how a human being becomes evil and how good.””
— Elizabeth Edwards Spalding

The Masterpiece that helped topple the USSR

In the Spring issue of the Claremont Review of Books, Lee Edwards reflects, in a ruminative essay, on The Gulag Archipelago at 50.

“Yet Solzhenitsyn did not despair. As he wrote Edward Erickson, Jr., who edited the one-volume abridgment of The Gulag Archipelago, he considered himself “an unshakable optimist.” The day before he was forced into exile, he said that “Gulag was destined to affect the course of history. I was sure of that.” He added: “You Bolsheviks are finished—there are no two ways about it.” The Gulag Archipelago played no small role in that happy outcome.”
— Lee Edwards

Masterpiece of Our Time

Nikolai Getman, The Gulag Collection: The Preacher, 1988, Oil on canvas, Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation, Washington, D.C.

In this month’s New Criterion, Gary Saul Morson pays tribute to The Gulag Archipelago at 50, hailing it as “the masterpiece of our time”.

“Why doesn’t Solzhenitsyn’s catalogue of horrors grow boring? You read three long volumes about boots trampling on human faces and your attention never flags. One reason is that Solzhenitsyn, like Edward Gibbon, is a master of ironic narration. At times, the book is unexpectedly funny. Along with The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, it stands as one of the great satires of world literature.

But it is the nature of Solzhenitsyn’s “experiment in literary investigation” that best explains why this book remains riveting. Gulag is structured as what might be called a collective autobiography. Readers learn about Solzhenitsyn’s personal experiences, and the author also records the analogous experiences of others. He seems to say: here is how I was arrested, and now here is how it happened to others; here is how I addressed the moral choices I faced; others reacted differently. Stalin is supposed to have said that one death is a tragedy but a million is a statistic. Through collective autobiography, Solzhenitsyn allows the reader to sense, if not a million tragedies, then at least many thousands of individual ones.”
— Gary Saul Morson

Watch Victims of Communism roundtable On The Gulag Archipelago

Yesterday in Washington, DC, the Victims of Communism held a roundtable event commemorating the 50th anniversary of The Gulag Archipelago. Featured speakers were Dr. Lee Edwards, Dr. Daniel J. Mahoney, Dr. Elizabeth Spalding, Dr. Flagg Taylor IV, Dr. David Walsh, and Robert Williams. Watch video of entire event below, from C-SPAN’s BookTV.

Le Figaro special Solzhenitsyn issue

The esteemed French daily newspaper, Le Figaro, has presented a rich panoply of materials in its 15 December 2023 issue, timed for the 50th anniversary of the first publication of The Gulag Archipelago (in Russian in Paris in December 1973) and to the new grand exhibition on Solzhenitsyn’s life that opens today in the Vendée.

We present the materials below in PDF, with a brief explanation of each:

on page 1, there is a tremendous editorial by Étienne de Montety, entitled “Géant et prophète” (“Giant and Prophet”), that eloquently expresses Solzhenitsyn’s unending relevance today.

“In December 1973, a book was published in Paris that hit like a bombshell. Its author possessed the stature and intimidating presence of a character from a Dostoevsky novel.”
— Étienne de Montety, Le Figaro

on page 18, there is a Guillaume Perrault article, “Il y a 50 ans, « L’Archipel du Goulag » de Soljenitsyne” (“50 Years Ago, Solzhenitsyn’s Gulag Archipelago”). Written in tight, present-tense prose, this is a blow-by-blow account of Solzhenitsyn’s life until the moment of his expulsion to the West in February 1974.

“In late December 1973, a famous book—written in secret by a great Russian author and smuggled to the West—was published in Paris. In it, he defies the leaders of the USSR, putting his own life on the line. Its pages would profoundly shake France and the entire Western world. Communism would never recover.”
— Guillaume Perrault, Le Figaro

on the cover page of the LE FIGARO ET VOUS section, there is a giant photo of Solzhenitsyn with the headline: “La Leçon d’ Histoire d’un Géant” (The Giant’s History Lesson”).

on pages 32–33 there is an Étienne de Montety interview with Ignat Solzhenitsyn: “La mission de mon père qui consistait à parler et à être la mémoire d’un peuple qui avait perdu sa voix” (“my father’s all-encompassing mission was to be the memory of a people who had lost their voice”).

“my father’s all-encompassing mission was to be the memory of a people who had lost their voice.”
— Ignat Solzhenitsyn

on those same pages 32–33 Dorian Grelier describes the sweep and power of the grand exhibition on Solzhenitsyn’s life opening tomorrow in the Vendée.

finally, on page 33, Paul-François Paoli offers a remembrance of Solzhenitsyn’s historic September 1993 speech at the dedication of the Vendée Memorial, and the bloody legacy of the 1794 massacre it commemorates.

Ignat Solzhenitsyn Interview with Amos Chapple on The Gulag Archipelago

RFE/RL has posted a new interview with Ignat Solzhenitsyn, conducted by Amos Chapple, on the enduring legacy of The Gulag Archipelago 50 years after its publication.

“Ignat, who is now a famed conductor and pianist living in New York, says The Gulag Archipelago “has never stopped being relevant,” for its “meditation on the nature of evil, and on the true nature of Marxism and communism.”

His father’s great insight, Ignat believes, was that evil exists not within any group that can be marked out, but as a kernel within every ordinary person, waiting for the climate and dark soil to sprout.”
— Amos Chapple

Mahoney Essay for the 50th anniversary of The Gulag Archipelago

Art by beck & Stone

Daniel J. Mahoney has a broad new essay over at Law and Liberty, reflecting on the 50th anniversary of The Gulag Archipelago.

“Communism, and modern theory and practice more broadly, has increasing turned human beings away from the things of the spirit, from the wellsprings of conscience, from the rich and enduring intimations of natural justice and God’s grace.”
— Daniel J. Mahoney

A video companion to the Gulag Archipelago

A young lady, Desi-Rae Campbell, writes us:

“I want to share this video series that I did covering The Gulag Archipelago. Although reading the book is the best way to absorb the content, it is useful for people who both have and do not want to read the book or can't for various reasons. It also includes relevant imagery and footage. Here is the full playlist” below. We thought it worth sharing with readers of that epic work.

The Gulag in Writings of Solzhenitsyn and Shalamov

A new book thoughtfully illuminates the respective treatments of the Gulag in the writings of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn and Varlam Shalamov, even if the editors and contributors generally approach camp literature and testimony from a literary, moral, and philosophical perspective closer to Shalamov than Solzhenitsyn. Two essays stand out: Michael N. Nicholson's lucid and informative account of the genesis of both the Kolyma Tales and One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich; and Luba Jurgenson's suggestive account of why Solzhenitsyn and Shalamov ended up not collaborating on The Gulag Archipelago.

College Student Writes Symphony inspired by Gulag Archipelago

Happy New Year, dear readers!

Young composer Austin Hamilton writes us: “Last year, I read The Gulag Archipelago and was so moved by his story that I dedicated part of my musical studies in my senior year of college to writing a symphony based off of the book. It was performed and recorded as a part of my senior recital. If nothing else, I'm writing to share my art in memory of Solzhenitsyn and the message he left us with.”

We are touched by Mr Hamilton’s sincerity and talent, and are pleased to share his video below, followed by his own program note.

00:00 Background
02:38 Movement I
10:12 Movement II
18:36 Movement III

The Symphony for the Zeki is written to remember and educate about the systems of gulags in the Soviet Union and their millions of prisoners, known as the zeki. Gulags were labor and death camps run by the government to imprison their own citizens, usually political prisoners. The inspiration for this symphony is rooted in Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn’s book The Gulag Archipelago, which recounts his own eleven years in labor camps and exile, along with stories from some two-hundred survivors. This book played a pivotal role in the downfall of the Soviet Union and shed light on what was behind the Iron Curtain. Each movement is titled after a chapter from the book.

Movement I: The History of Our Sewage Disposal System opens with La Internationale, which for many years was the Soviet national anthem, and is still used by many socialist and communist parties today. This movement depicts the waves of arrests, interrogations, and transfers of prisoners by train into the Gulag, never to see their families again. Many remember “the sharp nighttime ring or the rude knock at the door.” Many of those who were arrested were later tortured into giving forced confessions.

Movement II: The Archipelago Rises from the Sea describes the time spent within the Gulag. The prisoners experienced unimaginable working conditions, but somehow found the will to continue until the end of their sentence. Yet when prisoners were released, some would quickly pass away, having fought for so long. The prisoners were not the only victims of the Gulag—the torturers’ souls departed “downward from humanity” according to their grievous actions. And that underworld of Russian thieves held the credo: “you today; me tomorrow,” which was their constant reminder of how quickly things could change.

Movement III: The Ascent portrays the rise of the soul of the prisoner within the camp. Solzhenitsyn met Dr. Boris Nikolayevich Kornfeld after an operation on his malignant tumor in the camp hospital. Dr. Kornfeld kept Solzhenitsyn company that night and recounted the story of his conversion from Judaism to Christianity. Before departing, he left this final thought with Solzhenitsyn, which happened to be his final words as he was murdered the next morning: “I have become convinced that there is no punishment that comes to us in this life on earth which is undeserved. Superficially it can have nothing to do with what we are guilty of in actual fact, but if you go over your life with a fine-tooth comb and ponder it deeply, you will always be able to hunt down that transgression of yours for which you have now received this blow.” It was this that allowed Solzhenitsyn to accept the atrocities in his life and ascend high above the suffering and pain that surrounded him in the physical world.

Soviet Tyranny Warmed Over Is Still Tyranny

American Thinker.png

Over at American Thinker, E. M. Cadwaladr reads The Gulag Archipelago and worries about politics in today’s America as an end-all.

“In short, the grandest and most chilling similarity between Solzhenitsyn’s Soviet Union and today’s America is this: the needs of the political narrative reign supreme. Facts have been dethroned. In our old republic, policies were usually the result of compromises. They balanced, however imperfectly, the natural interests of a competing real persons. In a totalitarian state, the collective populace is simply forced into the mold required by the needs of the ideology itself. The idea justifies both means and ends. What happens to the individual matters — and in fact is worth mentioning — only if it happens to advance the progress of the narrative. Truth, as the postmodernists have openly told us, is what authorities say it is. In such a world, you and I are nothing at all.”
— E. M. Cadwaladr

The Other Solzhenitsyn now out in paperback

The Other Solzhenitsyn paperback cover.png

Daniel J. Mahoney’s second Solzhenitsyn book, The Other Solzhenitsyn: Telling the Truth about a Misunderstood Writer and Thinker, has now come out in paperback from St. Augustine’s Press. It is an insightful exploration of the philosophical, political, and moral themes in The Gulag Archipelago, The Red Wheel, and In the First Circle, among other works.

America’s Muzzled Freedom

Law & Liberty.png

Over at Law and Liberty, Scott Yenor has another take on Solzhenitsyn’s great Archipelago chapter, “Our Muzzled Freedom”. (Attentive readers will recall that we mentioned another paraphrase of that chapter’s famous list a few weeks ago.

“In the style and language of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, then, it is worth considering the attributes of America’s new, “muzzled freedom.”*”