Articles, Essays, and Speeches > Harvard Address

Harvard Address

Solzhenitsyn's Commencement Address
Harvard University
June 8, 1978


I am pleased at the opportunity to greet the 327th graduating class of this old and illustrious Harvard University, and I heartily salute all the graduates.

The motto of your university is “Veritas.” Some of you already know, and others will find out in the course of their lives, that Truth slips away from us the moment we take our eye off it, all the while leaving the illusion that we continue to follow in its path. This kindles much discord. Also, truth is seldom sweet, but almost invariably bitter. A measure of that bitter taste is unavoidable in today’s speech, too—yet I offer it as no adversary, but as a friend.

Three years ago here in the United States I had other occasion to say things that prompted pushback or that people did not want to accept—but with which many have now come to agree.


A World Split Apart

The split in today’s world is perceptible even to a hasty glance. Any of our contemporaries readily identifies two world powers, each of them already capable of utterly destroying the other. However, the understanding of that split is too often confined to this political conception, this illusion that danger may be abolished through successful diplomatic negotiations or by achieving a balance of armed forces. In reality, the split is both more profound and more alienating, its fissures more numerous than one can see at first glance; and this deep, manifold split threatens us all with equally manifold ruin, in accordance with the ancient truth that a kingdom divided against itself—in this case, our Earth—cannot stand. 

Contemporary Worlds 

There exists the concept of a Third World: thus, we already have three worlds. Undoubtedly, however, their number is even greater; we are just too far away to make them out. Every ancient and deeply rooted, self-contained, culture, especially if it is spread over a wide part of the earth’s surface, constitutes a self-contained world, full of riddles and surprises for Western thinking. Such, at the very least, are China, India, the Muslim world, and Africa—if indeed we accept the approximation of viewing the latter two as uniform. Such, for one thousand years, was Russia, although Western thinking systematically erred in denying its special character and therefore never understood it, just as it fails to understand it today in its Communist captivity. And while it may be that in recent decades Japan has increasingly become a “Far West,” drawing ever closer to Western ways (I am no judge here), Israel, I think, can hardly be reckoned as part of the Western world, if only because of the decisive circumstance that its state system is fundamentally linked to religion.

How short a time ago, relatively, the small world of a young Europe was easily seizing colonies all over the globe, not only without anticipating any real resistance but usually with contempt for any possible value in the conquered peoples’ approach to life. It all seemed an overwhelming success, with no geographic limits. Western society expanded in a triumph of human independence and might—a triumph that the twentieth century suddenly and clearly revealed to be fragile and fleeting. We see now how short-lived and precarious those conquests proved to be (and this, in turn, apparently points to defects in that Western worldview that led to these conquests). Relations with the former colonial world have now swung to the opposite extreme, with the Western world often displaying a surfeit of obsequiousness, but it is difficult to estimate the size of the bill that the former colonial countries will present to the West, and to predict whether the surrender not only of its last colonies but even of everything it owns will be sufficient for it to pay off this account.


Convergence

But the persisting blindness of superiority continues to support the belief that all the vast regions of our planet should develop and mature towards the level of contemporary Western systems, the most evolved in theory and the most attractive in practice; that all those other worlds are but temporarily prevented—by wicked rulers, or by severe crises, or by their own barbarity and incomprehension—from striking off along the path of Western multiparty democracy and adopting the Western way of life. Countries are judged on the degree of their progress in that direction. But in fact such a conception is a fruit of Western incomprehension of the essence of other worlds, a result of mistakenly measuring them all with a Western yardstick. The real picture of our planet’s development bears little resemblance to all this.

The anguish of a world split apart has also brought to life the theory of convergence between a leading West and the Soviet Union—a soothing theory, which overlooks the fact that these worlds are in no wise evolving toward each other, and that neither one can actually be transformed into the other without violence. Besides, convergence inevitably includes acceptance of the other side’s defects, too, and this is unlikely to suit anyone.

If I were today addressing an audience in my country, I would be concentrating, in my examination of the overall scheme of the world’s split, on the calamities of the East. But since my forced exile here has now lasted four years and my audience is a Western one, I think greater substance will be found in concentrating on certain aspects of the contemporary West, as I see them.


A Decline in Courage

A decline in courage may be the most striking feature that an outside observer notices in the West today. The Western world has lost its civic courage, both as a whole and separately, in each country, in each government, in each political party, and, of course, in the United Nations. Such a decline in courage is particularly noticeable among the ruling and intellectual elites, causing an impression of a loss of courage by the entire society. There remain many courageous individuals, but they have no determining influence on public life. Political and intellectual functionaries exhibit this depression, passivity, and perplexity in their actions and in their statements, and even more so in their self-serving rationales as to how realistic, reasonable, and intellectually and even morally justified it is to base state policies on weakness and cowardice. And the decline in courage, at times attaining what could be termed a lack of manhood, is ironically emphasized by occasional outbursts of boldness and inflexibility on the part of those same functionaries when dealing with weak governments and with countries that lack support, or with doomed currents which clearly cannot offer any resistance. But they get tongue-tied and paralyzed when they deal with powerful governments and threatening forces, with aggressors and international terrorists.

Must one point out that from ancient times a decline in courage has been considered the first symptom of the end?


Well-Being

When the modern Western states were being formed, it was proclaimed as a principle that governments are meant to serve man, and that man exists on earth in order to be free and pursue happiness (see, for example, the American Declaration of Independence). And now at last, in the course of the last few decades, technical and social progress has permitted the realization of such aspirations—the welfare state. Every citizen has been granted long-sought freedom and material goods in such quantity, and of such quality, as to guarantee in theory the achievement of happiness—in that debased sense that has arisen during those same decades. (In the process, however, one psychological detail has been overlooked: the constant desire to have still more things and a still better life, as well as the struggle to this end, imprint many Western faces with worry and even depression, though it is customary to carefully conceal such expressions. This active, tense competition comes to dominate all human thought and hardly swings open a path to a free development of the spirit.) The individual’s independence from many types of state pressure has been guaranteed; the majority of people have been provided with comforts to an extent their fathers and grandfathers couldn’t have even imagined; it has become possible to raise young people, too, according to these ideals, preparing them for and summoning them toward physical flourishing, happiness, the possession of material goods, money, and leisure, toward an almost unlimited freedom in the choice of pleasures. . . . So who should now renounce all this? why and for the sake of what should one risk one’s precious life in defense of the common good, and particularly in the nebulous case when the security of one’s nation must be defended in an as-yet-distant land?

Even biology tells us that a high degree of habitual well-being is hardly advantageous to a living organism. Today in the life of Western society, too, well-being has begun to peel off its pernicious mask.


Legalistic Life

Western society has chosen for itself the structure most convenient and best-suited to its purposes, one that I might call legalistic. Here the (very broad) limits of human rights and rightness are determined by a system of laws. Westerners have acquired considerable skill and staunchness in using, interpreting, and navigating this legalism (though laws tend to be so complicated that an average person is helpless to act without expert help). Every conflict is solved legalistically—and this is considered the highest form of decision making. If one is right, legally speaking—nothing more is required; nobody may point out to him that he might still not be entirely right, urge self-limitation or a renunciation of these rights, call for some kind of sacrifice or selfless risk: all this would sound simply absurd. Voluntary self-limitation is almost unheard-of: everybody strives, instead, to expand legalistic frames until they begin to creak. (Legally, an oil company is blameless when it buys up an invention of a new type of energy in order to prevent its use. Legally, food-product manufacturers are blameless when they poison their products to make them last longer: after all, people are free not to purchase them.)

Having spent all my life under a Communist regime, I will say that a society without any objective legal scale is a terrible one indeed. But a society with no scale but the legal one is also scarcely worthy of man. [Applause.] A society grounded in law but never reaching any higher takes but poor advantage of the full range of human potential. The letter of the law is too cold and formal to have a beneficial influence on society. When the entire tissue of life is woven of legalistic relationships, there materializes an atmosphere of spiritual mediocrity that deadens man’s noblest impulses. [Applause.]

As for the menacing age that draws near, it will be simply impossible to bear up under its trials braced only by the supports of legalism.


The Tilt of Freedom

In present-day Western society an inequality has come into view between the freedom for good deeds and the freedom for evil ones. A statesman who wants to achieve something important and constructive for his country is forced to step cautiously and even timidly; thousands of hasty (and irresponsible) critics cling to him at all times; he is constantly rebuffed by parliament and the press. He is obliged to prove that his every step is well-founded and absolutely faultless. Indeed, an outstanding, truly great person who has unusual and unexpected initiatives in mind gets no chance to show himself; dozens of traps will be set for him right from the beginning. Thus does mediocrity triumph under the guise of democratic restraints.

Everywhere it is feasible and easy to undermine administrative power, and it has indeed been drastically weakened in all Western countries. The defense of individual rights has reached such extremes as to make society, as a whole, defenseless [applause] against certain individuals—so the time has come in the West to defend not so much human rights as human obligations. [Applause.]

On the other hand, destructive and irresponsible freedom has been granted ample space. Society has turned out to have scarce defense against the abyss of human decadence, for example against the misuse of liberty for moral violence against young people, such as films full of pornography, violence, and horror [applause]: all these are considered to be part of freedom and to be counterbalanced, in theory, by the young people’s right not to look and not to accept. Thus has the legalistic life shown its inability to defend itself against the corrosion of evil.

And what shall we say about the dark realms of outright criminality? Legal limits (especially in the United States) are broad enough to encourage not only individual freedom but also certain violations of it; the culprit can go unpunished or obtain undeserved leniency—all with the support of thousands of defenders in society. When a government somewhere earnestly undertakes to root out terrorism, public opinion immediately accuses it of violating the bandits’ civil rights. [Applause.] There are quite a number of such cases.

This entire tilt of freedom toward evil has come about gradually, but its primary foundation, evidently, was laid by the humanistic and benevolent notion according to which man—the master of this world—bears no intrinsic evil within himself, and all the vices of life stem from faulty social systems, which must therefore be corrected. Yet strangely enough, though the best social conditions have been achieved in the West, there remains a great deal of crime—in fact, considerably more of it than in the destitute and lawless Soviet society. (There is an enormous multitude of prisoners in our camps who are termed criminals, but the overwhelming majority of them never committed any crime—only tried to defend themselves against a lawless state by resorting to means outside the legal framework.)


The Orientation of the Press

The broadest freedom is, of course, also enjoyed by the press (I shall be using this word to include all media.)

Here again, the overriding concern is not to infringe on the legalistic framework; there is no true moral responsibility for distortion or disproportion. What sort of responsibility do a journalist or a newspaper have to their readership or to history? If they have misled public opinion through inaccurate information or wrong conclusions, if they’ve even abetted mistakes on a state level, do we know of any case of open regret voiced by that journalist or that newspaper? No—this would damage sales. A nation may be the worse for such a mistake, but the journalist always comes out smelling like roses. Chances are, he will now start writing, with renewed aplomb, the exact opposite of what he wrote previously.

Because instant, authoritative information is required, it becomes necessary to resort to guesswork, rumors, and suppositions to fill in the voids—and none of them will ever be refuted, but will instead settle into the public’s memory. How many hasty, rash, immature, and misleading judgments are expressed every day, hoodwinking readers—and then hardening in place. [Applause.] The press has the opportunity both to simulate public opinion and to miseducate it. Thus we may see terrorists heroized, or secret matters pertaining even to the nation’s defense publicly revealed, or shameless intrusions into the privacy of well-known people according to the slogan “Everyone is entitled to know everything.” [Applause.] (But this is a false slogan of a false age; far greater in value is the forfeited right of people not to know, not to have their divine souls stuffed with gossip, nonsense, vain talk. [Applause.] A person who labors diligently and leads a meaningful life has no need at all for this excessive and burdening flow of information.)

Superficiality and haste—the psychological maladies of the twentieth century—manifest themselves, more than anywhere else, in the press. In-depth analysis of a problem is anathema to the press, contrary to its nature; instead, it merely plucks out sensational formulations.

Such as it is, however, the press has become the dominant power in Western countries, exceeding that of the executive, the legislature, and the judiciary. Yet one would like to ask: according to what law has it been elected and to whom is it accountable? In the Communist East, a journalist is openly appointed as a state official—but who has voted Western journalists into their positions of power? for what length of term and with what prerogatives?

There is yet another surprise for someone coming from the totalitarian East with its rigidly unified press: one discovers, within the Western press as a whole, a common orientation of preferences (the spirit of the age), a commonly accepted framework of judgment, and at times even common corporate interests, the sum effect being not competition but standardization. Unrestrained freedom exists for the press, but not for their readership [applause], as newspapers prominently and emphatically convey only those opinions which don’t overly contradict their own and that common orientation.


Fashionable Ideas

Without any censorship in the West, fashionable ideas are fastidiously separated from unfashionable ones, and the latter, without ever being forbidden, have no real chance of finding their way into periodicals or books, or of being voiced from university lecterns. [Applause.] Your scholars are free in the legal sense, but they’re hemmed in by the idols of prevailing fashion. Not through open violence, as in the East, but through this selection—governed by fashion and the need to cater to mass standards—the most independent-minded persons are thwarted from contributing to public life, and there appear dangerous features of herd mentality, blocking the path of effective evolution. In America I have at times received letters from highly intelligent persons—maybe a professor in a faraway small college who might do much for the renewal and salvation of his country—but the country can’t hear him because the media won’t offer him a forum. This gives rise to strong mass prejudices, to a blindness that is perilous in our dynamic age—for example, an illusory understanding of the present world situation, a kind of armor so petrified around people’s minds that human voices from fourteen countries of Eastern Europe and East Asia[i] can no longer pierce it; it will be smashed only by the inexorable crowbar of events.

I have enumerated a few traits of Western life that shock a new arrival to this world. The scope and purpose of this speech do not allow me to continue such a survey and examine how these particularities of Western society impact important aspects of a nation’s life, such as primary education, advanced education in the humanities, and art.

[i] “Fourteen countries of Eastern Europe and East Asia”: Solzhenitsyn likely has in mind eight Communist countries in Eastern Europe (Albania, Yugoslavia, Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Poland, East Germany) and six in East Asia (Mongolia, Red China, North Korea, Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia).


Socialism

It is almost universally recognized that the West shows all the world the way to successful economic development, even if undermined recently by chaotic inflation. However, many people living in the West are dissatisfied with their society, deride it, or accuse it of no longer being up to the level of maturity attained by mankind. And this causes many to sway toward the false and dangerous current of socialism.

I hope that no one present will suspect me of expressing my partial criticism of the Western system in order to suggest socialism as an alternative. [Applause.] No; with the experience of a country where socialism has been realized, I shall certainly not speak for such an alternative. That socialism of any style and hue leads to a comprehensive destruction of the spiritual essence of man and to a leveling of mankind unto death has been demonstrated via penetrating historical analysis by the mathematician and academician Igor Shafarevich, in his brilliantly argued book,Socialism; it will soon be two years since its publication in France, but no one has yet managed to offer a rejoinder. Very soon it will also be published in America.


Not a Model

But should I be asked, instead, whether I would propose the West, such as it is today, as a model for my country, I would have to answer frankly: no, I could not recommend your society as an ideal for the transformation of ours. Given the fecund spiritual development already experienced by our country through profound suffering during this century, the Western system in its present state of spiritual exhaustion does not appear enticing. Even just those characteristics of your life that I’ve enumerated are extremely saddening.

An indubitable fact is the slackening of human character in the West and its strengthening in the East. Six decades for our people, and three decades for the peoples of Eastern Europe: during that time we have gone through a school of the soul that far outstrips Western experience. That complex and deadly crush of life has produced stronger, deeper, and more interesting characters than those generated by regulated Western well-being. Therefore, if our society were to be transformed into yours, it would mean an improvement in certain aspects but a deterioration in others—some of them especially precious. Of course, a society must not remain in such an abyss of lawlessness as is the case with us; yet how demeaning for it to linger on such a soulless legalistic plane as with you. After suffering decades of oppressive violence, the human soul longs for something higher, warmer, and purer than what is offered by today’s mass Western lifestyle, introduced as by a calling card by the revolting assault of advertising, by television stupor, and by intolerable music. [Applause.]

All this is visible to numerous observers from all the worlds of our planet. The Western way of life is less and less likely to become the leading model.

There are telltale signs by which history gives warning to a threatened or perishing society: such are, for instance, a decline of the arts or a dearth of great statesmen. Other times, the warnings are entirely tangible and quite explicit: the epicenter of your democracy and culture is left without electric power—for a few hours only—and, immediately, large throngs of American citizens rush to loot and ravage.[i] The smooth surface film, then, must be very thin, and the social system unstable and inwardly unhealthy.

But the fight for our planet—physical, spiritual, of cosmic proportions—is not a vague matter of the future: it has already started. Worldwide Evil has already begun, and is now pressing, its decisive offensive—yet your screens and publications are full of prescribed smiles and raised goblets. Celebrating what? . . .

[i] “Large throngs of American citizens rush to loot and ravage”: Solzhenitsyn is referring to the infamous New York City blackout of 13–14 July 1977 and the mayhem that unfolded over the course of its few short hours.


Shortsightedness

Your well-known public figures, such as George Kennan, say: “When it comes to the realm of grand politics, moral criteria can no longer be applied.”[i] Thus, in mixing up good and evil, right and wrong, do we prepare fertile ground for the absolute triumph of absolute Evil in the world. Against Communism’s well-planned global strategy it is only moral criteria that can help the West—there are no others [applause] . . . and practical considerations, meanwhile, will always be bested by strategic ones. Beyond a certain level of insight, legalistic thinking calcifies perception, preventing one from making out the scale or the meaning of events.

In spite of an abundance of information—or maybe partly because of it—the West has had some difficulty in finding its bearings amid contemporary events: such were the risible predictions by certain American experts that Angola would become the Soviet Union’s Vietnam, or that Cuba’s brazen excursions into Africa would be best tempered by American courtship. [Applause.] Kennan’s advice to his own country—to begin unilateral disarmament—belongs to the same category. Oh, if you only knew how the most junior of officials in Moscow’s Staraya Square[ii]double up with laughter at your political sages! [Applause.] As for Fidel Castro, he openly scorns the United States, boldly sending his troops to distant adventures from right under your nose.

However, the most serious blunder came with the failure to understand the Vietnam War. Some sincerely wanted all wars to stop just as soon as possible; others deemed it right to leave room for national or Communist self-determination in Vietnam (or in Cambodia, as we see especially vividly today). But in reality, members of the American antiwar movement turned out to be accomplices in the betrayal of Far Eastern nations, in the genocide and suffering that convulse 30 million people there today. Now do these committed pacifists hear that groaning? [applause] today do they recognize their responsibility? or do they prefer not to hear? The American intelligentsia lost its nerve and, in consequence, the danger has come much closer to America itself. But there is no awareness of this. Your shortsighted politician who signed the hasty Vietnam capitulation[iii] seemingly allowed America to stretch out in a carefree breathing pause—but lo, a hundredfold Vietnam now looms over you. Little Vietnam had been sent you as a warning and an occasion to mobilize your courage. But if the full might of America suffered comprehensive defeat at the hands of even a small Communist half-country, how can the West hope to stand firm in the future?

I have said on another occasion that in the twentieth century Western democracy has not won any major war by itself:[iv] each time it shielded itself with an ally possessing a powerful land army, whose worldview it did not scrutinize. Thus in World War II against Hitler, instead of winning the conflict with its own forces, which would certainly have been sufficient, Western democracy raised up another enemy, one that would prove a more bitter and powerful one, since Hitler had neither the resources nor the number of people, nor the forceful ideas, nor such a large number of supporters in the West—a fifth column—as the Soviet Union possessed. Some Western voices today are already calling for a new protective screen against hostile forces in the next world conflict: in this case, the shield would be China. But I would not wish such an outcome upon anyone in the world. Apart from again forming a doomed alliance with Evil, it would grant the United States but a brief reprieve: when China with its billion people might later turn around armed with American weapons, America itself would fall victim to a Cambodia-style genocide.


[i] “Moral criteria can no longer be applied”: the quote that Solzhenitsyn uses here—translated into Russian, of course—appears to stem from Kennan’s top-secret “Memo PPS23” from 1948 (not declassified until 1974), which contains an almost identical sentiment: “We should stop putting ourselves in the position of being our brothers’ keeper and refrain from offering moral and ideological advice. We should cease to talk about vague—and for the Far East—unreal objectives such as human rights, the raising of the living standards, and democratization. The day is not far off when we are going to have to deal in straight power concepts. The less we are hampered by idealistic slogans, the better.” Memo by George Kennan, Head of the US State Department Policy Planning Staff. Written February 28, 1948, declassified June 17, 1974. George Kennan, “Review of Current Trends, U.S. Foreign Policy, Policy Planning Staff, PPS No. 23. Top Secret. Included in the U.S. Department of State, Foreign Relations of the United States, 1948, volume 1, part 2 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1976), 525.

[ii] “Staraya Square”: a street in central Moscow (the name translates as “Old Square”), along which, in building number 4, was located the seat of the Central Committee of the CPSU; in common parlance, the street name itself became a euphemism for what, in the West, was conventionally referred to as “the Kremlin.”

[iii] “Your shortsighted politician who signed the hasty Vietnam capitulation”: Henry Kissinger, whose signature under the Paris Peace Accords of January 1973 effectively withdrew the United States from the Vietnam War and consigned South Vietnam to its doom.

[iv] “Western democracy has not won any major war by itself”: see “If One Doesn’t Wish to Be Blind,” 78 in this volume.


Loss of Will

And yet, no weaponry, no matter how powerful, can help the West unless it overcomes its loss of will. In a state of psychological enfeeblement, weapons themselves actually become burdensome for the capitulating side. To defend oneself, one must also be ready to die—but there is little such readiness in a society reared on the cult of earthly well-being. [Applause.] There remains nothing, then, but concessions, delays, and betrayal. Thus, at the shameful Belgrade conference,[i] free Western diplomats have surrendered, in their weakness, that line of defense for which enslaved members of the Helsinki Group[ii] are sacrificing their lives.

Western thinking has become conservative: just let the world situation remain as it is, just let nothing change. This debilitating dream of a status quo is the symptom of a society whose development has terminated. And one must be blind not to see that the oceans no longer belong to the West, while the land under its dominion keeps shrinking. The two so-called world wars—though they were by far not on a world scale, not yet—were really about the internal self-destruction of the small progressive West, which thereby prepared its own end. The next war—not necessarily an atomic one; I don’t believe it will be—may well bury Western civilization for good.

In the face of this danger, with such historical values in your past, with such a high level of attained freedom and apparent devotion to it, how is it possible to so thoroughly lose the will to defend oneself?

[i] “Shameful Belgrade conference”: the Belgrade Meeting (1977–78) of the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE).

[ii] “Helsinki Group”: The Moscow Helsinki (Watch) Group, like its sister organizations across the USSR and Eastern Europe, was a grassroots human-rights association set up by dissidents that attempted to monitor Soviet (non)adherence to the terms of the 1975 Helsinki Accords.


Humanism and Its Consequences

How has this unfavorable correlation of forces come about? How did the West decline from its triumphal march to its present debility? Have there been fatal turning points in its development? has it veered off course? No, it does not seem so. The West kept advancing ever forward in accordance with its proclaimed course, hand in hand with dazzling technological Progress. And suddenly it found itself in its present state of weakness.

It remains then to search for a fault at the root, at the very foundation of thought of the Modern Age. I refer to that prevailing Western worldview that was born in the Renaissance and has found political expression since the Age of Enlightenment. It became the basis for all political and social doctrine and could be called rationalistic humanism or humanistic autonomy: the proclaimed and practiced autonomy of man from any higher force above him. It could also be called anthropocentrism—the idea of man as the center of existence.

The turn effected by the Renaissance was probably inevitable historically: the Middle Ages had come to a natural end by exhaustion, having become intolerable through their despotic repression of man’s physical nature in favor of his spiritual one. But our ensuing headlong dash from the Spirit toward Matter was itself excessive and incommensurate. The humanistic way of thinking, which had proclaimed itself our guide, did not admit the existence of intrinsic evil in man, nor any task higher than the quest for earthly happiness; and it fashioned the dangerous tilt toward the worship of man and his material needs into the basis of modern Western civilization. Everything beyond physical well-being and the accumulation of material goods, all other human requirements and characteristics of a subtler and higher nature, were left outside the attention of state and social systems, as if human life had no higher purpose. Thus breaches were left open for evil, and its drafts blow freely today. Mere freedom per se does not in the least solve all the problems of human existence, and in fact poses a number of new ones.

And yet in early democracies, as in American democracy at the time of its birth, all individual rights were recognized on the premise that man is God’s creature; that is, freedom was given to the individual conditionally, under the assumption of his continuous religious responsibility. Such was the heritage of the preceding millennium. Just two hundred, or even fifty, years ago, it would have seemed impossible, in America, that an individual be granted unbridled freedom with no purpose, simply for the satisfaction of his cravings. Subsequently, however, all such limitations have eroded throughout the West, and there has come to pass a final emancipation from the moral heritage of Christian centuries, with their great reserves of mercy and sacrifice. State systems have become ever more consummately materialistic. The West has finally achieved the rights of man, even to excess—but man’s sense of accountability to God and society has grown utterly faint. In recent decades, the legalistic egoism of the Western worldview has reached its peak—and the world has found itself in a severe spiritual crisis and a political impasse. And all the technological achievements of our fabled Progress, including the conquest of outer space, cannot redeem the twentieth century’s moral poverty, which no one could have imagined as recently as the nineteenth century.


An Unexpected Kinship

As humanism in its development became more and more materialistic, it also increasingly allowed itself to be co-opted—first by socialism, and then by Communism: so that Karl Marx was able to say, in 1844, that “Communism is naturalized humanism.”

This statement has proved to be not entirely unreasonable. One can indeed discern the same cornerstones in the foundations of eroded humanism and of every style of socialism: boundless materialism; freedom from religion and religious responsibility (under Communism attaining the stage of anti-religious dictatorship); concentration on social structures with a pseudoscientific approach (eighteenth-century Enlightenment and then Marxism). It is no accident that all of Communism’s rhetorical vows revolve around Man (with a capital M) and his earthly happiness. At first glance it seems an ungainly parallel—common traits in the worldview and way of life of today’s West and today’s East?—but such is the logic of materialism’s development.

The correlation of kinship is such, moreover, that the current of materialism farthest to the left, and hence the most consistent, always proves to be more potent, more attractive, more triumphant. Humanism, having squandered its Christian heritage, cannot prevail in this contest. Thus, during the past centuries and especially in recent decades, as the process has become more acute, the worldwide correlation of forces progressed as follows: liberalism was inevitably pushed aside by radicalism, radicalism had to yield to socialism, and socialism couldn’t hold its ground against Communism. The Communist system in the East could endure and strengthen owing only to zealous support from an enormous number of Western intellectuals who (feeling that kinship!) refused to see Communism’s crimes, and when they could no longer do so, tried to justify them. The same is true today: back East, Communism has suffered an utter ideological defeat; it has fallen to zero and less than zero; yet Western intellectuals still view it with considerable interest and empathy—and it’s this that makes it so immensely difficult for the West to withstand the East.


Before the Turn

I’m not considering the case of a global military catastrophe and the changes that it would trigger in society. But while we yet wake every day under a peaceful sun, so too must we lead an everyday life. Yet, another catastrophe is already very much with us: the catastrophe of an autonomous, irreligious humanistic consciousness.

It has made man the measure of all things on Earth: imperfect man, who’s never been free of pride, self-interest, envy, vanity, and dozens of other vices. Thus, the errors misperceived at the beginning of the journey now take their revenge. That journey since the Renaissance has enriched our experience, but we have forsaken something Whole, something Supreme, which once delimited both our passions and our irresponsibility. We threw all our hopes into political and social reforms—only to find that we were being robbed of our most precious possession: our inner life. It is being stamped out by the party mob in the East, by the commercial one in the West. [Applause.] This is the fearsome essence of the crisis: not just that the world is split apart, but that its major shards are stricken with a similar malady.

If, as claimed by humanism, man were born only to be happy, he would not also be born to die. Since his body is doomed to death, his task on earth must evidently be more spiritual: not to gorge on everyday life, not to search for the best ways of obtaining material goods and then to consume them eagerly, but to bear perpetual, earnest duty, so that one’s entire life journey may become, above all, an experience of moral ascent [applause]—to leave life a better human being than one started it. It is imperative to reappraise the scale of widespread human values and to marvel at its present inaptness. It must not be that the assessment of a president’s performance is reduced to the question of how much money one makes, or to the availability of gasoline. [Applause.] Only by the voluntary nurturing within ourselves of serene self-limitation can mankind rise above the world stream of materialism.

To cling today to the ossified formulas of the Enlightenment is retrogressive. Such social dogmatism leaves us helpless before the trials of our age.

Even if we are spared destruction by war, life will inevitably change so as not itself to perish. We cannot avoid reassessing the fundamental definitions of human life and human society: is man truly above everything, and is there no Supreme Spirit above him? is it right that man’s life and society’s activities should be defined by material expansion above all? and is it permissible to promote such expansion to the detriment of our integral inner life?

If the world hasn’t approached its ruin, it has surely reached a turn in history, equal in importance to the turn from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance. It will demand from us a spiritual epiphany, an ascent to a new height of vision, to a new level of life, where neither will our physical nature be consigned to perdition—as in the Middle Ages—nor will our spiritual nature, all the more crucially, be trampled upon, as in the Modern Era. [Applause.]

This ascent is akin to scaling the next anthropological stage. And no one on Earth has any other way left but—upward. [Applause.]

------------------------------------------------------------------------

translated from the Russian by Irina Ilovaiskaya-Alberti


Blogposts about harvard address

AVAILABLE FORMATS


We Have Ceased to See the Purpose: Essential Speeches of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, ed. Ignat Solzhenitsyn, Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 2025)
Hardcover
Amazon | Barnes & Noble
E-Book
Kindle | Apple Books | Nook

The Solzhenitsyn Reader
Hardcover
Amazon
Paperback
Amazon | Barnes & Noble